Matt Nance
matt@responsiveinsurance.com
Owner and Principal Agent
Matt Nance founded Responsive Insurance in January 2013. The agency has grown to over 2,500 active clients. While leading the vision and operations of the agency, Matt remains involved in client relationships and team development. Under his leadership, Responsive Insurance was recognized as a Big “I” Best Practices Agency in 2025, a testament to the teams commitment to excellence and personalized service.
Originally from Mount Vernon, Indiana, Matt moved to Naples in 2006 and began his insurance career at a local Allstate agency. He and his wife, Casey, have been married since 2009 and are proud parents of two daughters, now 18 and 14. Their family enjoys traveling together and exploring the beauty of God’s creation. They share their home with Millie, a playful Portipoo.
Matt is a member of BNI, where he values building connections and sharing referrals. He has served his community through roles on his HOA board and in capacities within his local congregation. Matt continues to enjoy being a business owner and growing alongside his team.
